Showing posts with label War. Show all posts
Showing posts with label War. Show all posts

🎞️ Review: The Best Years of Our Lives (1946): Eighty Years Later, Still the Best

Homer Parrish (Harold Russell), Al Stephenson (Fredric March), and Fred Derry (Dana Andrews), three World War II veterans struggling to adjust to civilian life in The Best Years of Our Lives (1946).

Some films are great, some are masterpieces, and then there are the rare ones that become a part of you. William Wyler's The Best Years of Our Lives (1946) is one of those films. In fact, it is my favorite film of all time. 

On this day, November 21, 1946, this extraordinary picture opened in New York. Eighty years later, I still consider it one of the most perfectly realized films ever made. I've watched it more times than I can count, read countless articles about it, and discussed it endlessly. Yet somehow, it never loses its emotional impact. Certain scenes still bring a lump to my throat, even though I know every moment that's coming.


 

I've wanted to write about The Best Years of Our Lives for quite some time, but with so many wonderful tributes already out there, I've often wondered what I could possibly add. And with its 80th anniversary upon us, I can't think of a better time to finally sit down and write about it. Rather than another conventional review, I wanted to share why this movie has meant so much to me, why I think it's practically perfect, and why, after all these years, it still gets to me.

My history with The Best Years of Our Lives goes back nearly thirty years, to around 1996, when I was taking a college film studies class on war films and Westerns. For my thesis, I explored how women were portrayed in 1940s war films, particularly So Proudly We Hail! (1943) and The Best Years of Our Lives (1946). At the time, I was just doing research for a college paper. I had no idea one of those films would become my all-time favorite.

I had always loved classic films, but this was one of the first times I truly understood just how powerful cinema could be. A movie could do more than entertain. It could make you think differently about history, human relationships, sacrifice, and the world around you. It could leave you with feelings you didn't quite know how to explain, feelings that stayed with you long after the picture ended.

That's what The Best Years of Our Lives did for me.


 

One thing I've always admired about The Best Years of Our Lives is how different it was from so many other Hollywood films of its time. When it came out in 1946, it moved away from the usual wartime heroics and escapism to show what happened after the fighting ended and the men finally came home. And coming home wasn't necessarily the happy ending everyone expected. The film dealt with the real problems returning veterans faced, from emotional trauma and physical disabilities to unemployment, financial worries, and marriages that weren't quite the same anymore.

Despite tackling some pretty difficult subjects, The Best Years of Our Lives became a massive box-office success, ranking as the highest-grossing film of 1946 and one of the biggest hits since Gone with the Wind (1939). 

Three Men, Three Lives, One Unforgettable Story

Three servicemen return to their hometown of Boone City after World War II. Sounds simple enough, doesn't it? But nothing about what awaits them is simple.


 

We first meet Al Stephenson (Fredric March), Fred Derry (Dana Andrews), and Homer Parrish (Harold Russell) as they make their way home. They come from different walks of life, different branches of the service, and different social and economic backgrounds. Yet they form an immediate bond. They've shared something that the people waiting back home can never fully understand.

Al is an Army sergeant and a well-established banker returning to a comfortable home, a loving wife, Milly (Myrna Loy), and their two children, Peggy (Teresa Wright) and teenage son Rob (Michael Hall). Fred is a decorated Army Air Forces captain and bombardier from a working-class background who discovers that the prestige he enjoyed in uniform means very little in civilian life. And Homer, a young Navy sailor who lost both hands during the war, struggles with his independence and worries that the people he loves will see him differently.


I love the way Wyler introduces these three men. As their plane approaches Boone City, they look down at the familiar landscape, trying to pick out places they remember. They're excited, naturally. They're finally going home! But you can sense the uncertainty, too. What exactly are they going home to?

And here's a little connection that makes this opening especially meaningful to me. Those aerial views include footage of Cincinnati, Ohio, which I now call home! I previously touched on this in my blog post, "Why Is Everybody from Ohio?" Imagine that! After loving this movie for so many years, I now live in a city that has its own place in the history of my favorite film. I get a kick out of that.

An aerial view featured in The Best Years of Our Lives (1946).

What I love about Wyler's direction is how naturally he tells their stories. These men aren't perfect, and he doesn't treat them as heroes just because they've been through a war. They're ordinary guys trying to get back to the lives they knew, only to find that things aren't quite the same anymore. And what baggage they bring home. Not just their suitcases, but the nightmares, fears, doubts, insecurities, and memories that no one waiting for them could ever fully understand.

During the war, people made decisions under extraordinary circumstances. Relationships began, promises were made, and futures were imagined. But what happens when the uniforms come off, the celebrations end, and reality sets in? The world has continued moving while these men were away, and the people they once were aren't necessarily the people they've become. The war may be over, but their battles are far from finished.

 

William Wyler: A Director Who Understood

William Wyler has always been my favorite director, and if I had to choose one film that best demonstrates his remarkable gifts, this would be it.

William Wyler on set


Wyler knew what it was like to return from war. During World War II, he served in the Army Air Forces, documenting combat through films such as The Memphis Belle (1944) and Thunderbolt! (1947). His experiences were dangerous, and he suffered permanent hearing damage. He returned to Hollywood with a different perspective, and I think you can see that experience reflected throughout this picture.

The origins of The Best Years of Our Lives are fascinating. Producer Samuel Goldwyn's wife, Frances, had read a 1944 Time magazine article about servicemen struggling to adjust to civilian life and suggested that it could become a film. Goldwyn commissioned novelist MacKinlay Kantor, who produced Glory for Me, a novel written in blank verse. Goldwyn was hardly enthusiastic about the result. Eventually, playwright Robert E. Sherwood transformed the material into the screenplay we know today.



Wyler was initially reluctant to take on the project, having recently joined the independent production company Liberty Films. Fortunately, he recognized the story's importance. And what a film he made! What I love about Wyler's direction is that he never has to show off. He knows exactly what he's doing, and he doesn't need to spell everything out. Sometimes all it takes is a look between two characters, a pause, or a moment of silence. And that's enough.

He also refuses to romanticize the homecoming experience. Yes, these men are welcomed back, but that doesn't mean everything suddenly falls into place. Their jobs, marriages, families, and even their sense of who they are have changed. Surviving the war was one thing. Learning how to live afterward is another.

And the casting! I honestly cannot imagine anyone else in these roles. The acting feels so natural and real.

 

A Homecoming That Gets Me Every Time

Of all the moments in the film, one of my absolute favorites is Al's homecoming.

Fredric March enters the family apartment, puts down his bags, and calls out. Myrna Loy, as his wife, Milly, appears at the far end of the hallway. 


She sees him, and in an instant, they rush into each other's arms. Oh, that scene! Sighs! No lengthy speeches. No elaborate declarations. Just two people reunited after years of uncertainty, holding on as if they never want to let go. It gets me every single time.


And I can't watch it without thinking about the countless real-life husbands, wives, parents, and children who experienced reunions just like this. The waiting, the worrying, the fear that someone might never return. And then, for those fortunate enough, that overwhelming moment of relief.


What makes the scene even more meaningful is that Wyler drew inspiration from his own wartime reunion with his wife, Talli. Myrna Loy is simply wonderful throughout the film. Her Milly is loving, perceptive, and much wiser than she initially appears. And can we talk about the fact that Loy wasn't even nominated for an Academy Award? Don't get me started! I think she absolutely deserved one! So much is going on beneath that calm, understanding exterior, and she makes it all look effortless.



I also love her conversation with Peggy about marriage, when she explains that even a seemingly happy relationship has its share of difficulties. I love that little bit of honesty. Milly knows perfectly well that marriage isn't all romance and happy endings. It takes patience, forgiveness, and plenty of work.

And then there's Al's drinking. He's back in his comfortable home, with his family, and at a good job at the bank. On the surface, he should have everything he needs to settle back into his old life. But it's not that simple. He's restless, uncomfortable, and drinking far too much. Those nights out with Milly and Peggy may have their funny moments, but something sad lies beneath all that drinking, too. Al is struggling, and the alcohol seems to be one way of dealing with feelings he can't quite put into words.

 

Myrna Loy as Milly Stephenson and Fredric March as Al Stephenson in The Best Years of Our Lives (1946).


Milly sees it. She knows her husband isn't quite the same man who left home, and she doesn't expect him to become his old self overnight. But she's no pushover, either. Loy plays her with wonderful strength. She loves Al, understands his difficulties, and knows finding their way back to the marriage they once had will take work.


And Fredric March is equally marvelous. His Al is affectionate, funny, occasionally exasperating, and deeply troubled by the changes he encounters. March certainly deserved his Academy Award for Best Actor.


Although I must admit, I've always felt that another actor in this film deserved that honor just as much, if not more.

 

Dana Andrews: The Performance That Breaks My Heart

Dana Andrews as Fred Derry is, to me, one of the finest performances of the entire decade.

 

Fred was a respected bombardier during the war, entrusted with enormous responsibility. Back home, however, he can barely find meaningful employment. His marriage to Marie (Virginia Mayo) is falling apart, and he's struggling to figure out where he belongs in a world that no longer seems to need him.

Imagine going from a decorated captain, responsible for the lives of others during dangerous bombing missions, to being treated as though your wartime accomplishments mean absolutely nothing. Fred once worked as a soda jerk, and now he faces the humiliating prospect of returning to the same kind of work. Those decorations on his uniform may have represented bravery and sacrifice, but they don't carry much weight when he's trying to earn a living.

And then there's the scene where Al confronts Fred about his relationship with Peggy. Al is worried about his daughter and wants Fred to stop seeing her. I love the way March and Andrews play this scene, sitting across from each other, with all that tension between them. Neither man needs to raise his voice to get his point across.


And there's another little scene that gets me every single time. When Fred's father reads aloud the citation that accompanied his son's military decorations, with Fred's mother listening beside him, I just about lose it. There's something so touching about the pride in his father's voice, especially knowing how much Fred is struggling to find his place in the world again.

Pat Derry (Roman Bohnen) reads his son Fred's Distinguished Flying Cross citation to his wife, Hortense (Gladys George)

 

And Dana Andrews! Those weary eyes, the way he carries himself, the frustration he tries so hard to keep bottled up. You can see what Fred is going through without him saying a word. What a performance!


Andrews and William Wyler also have a little history. Wyler gave Andrews his first film role in The Westerner (1940), so this wasn't their first time working together. By 1946, Andrews had already made a name for himself in films like Laura (1944) and Fallen Angel (1945). But Fred Derry was something quite different. Here was a decorated war hero who could face danger in the skies, yet couldn't seem to find his place in the world once he came home. And Andrews plays that frustration and quiet desperation so beautifully.

One of the most heartbreaking moments occurs when Fred experiences a traumatic nightmare about the war. He cries out in his sleep, reliving the terror of combat, and Peggy gently comforts him. It's such a tender scene, but also a painful reminder that the war has followed Fred home. He's physically safe, but those memories haven't gone anywhere.

Teresa Wright as Peggy Stephenson and Dana Andrews as Fred Derry

And then there's that unforgettable aircraft graveyard sequence.

 


Fred wanders among the abandoned bombers, reminders of a life when he had purpose and identity. As he sits inside the nose of a dismantled aircraft, the memories of combat seem to close in around him. It's a heartbreaking scene, and Andrews barely has to do anything. Just watching him sitting there, surrounded by the remains of those enormous machines, tells us so much about what he's lost and how uncertain his future has become.


I've always believed Andrews should have received an Academy Award nomination, and I would have loved to see him win Best Actor. His omission remains one of my great Oscar disappointments.

The contrast between the two women in Fred's life is equally fascinating. Virginia Mayo's Marie fell in love with a handsome, decorated serviceman. The uniform, the shiny medals, the excitement of marrying an officer. How glamorous it must have seemed. But when Fred comes home, trades his uniform for civilian clothes, and struggles to find work, suddenly the glamour isn't quite so appealing.

Virginia Mayo as Marie Derry

There's something rather cruel about that. The very things that once made Fred so desirable no longer seem to matter to Marie. She wants the excitement and security she imagined marriage would bring, but she's hardly prepared for the reality of living with a struggling veteran.


Now, I don't think Marie should be dismissed as merely selfish, although she certainly has her moments. She represents another side of wartime romance: people falling in love under extraordinary circumstances without really knowing what life together would be like once the war ended.

Peggy, on the other hand, sees Fred for who he is. Not the captain, not the medals, not the uniform. Just Fred.


And Teresa Wright brings such sincerity to Peggy. I love the quiet strength of her performance. She's compassionate without being a pushover, and she's certainly aware that her feelings for Fred are complicated because he's married. But she recognizes the good man beneath all that frustration and disappointment.




Harold Russell and the Courage to Be Vulnerable

Then there's Harold Russell.


Russell wasn't a professional actor. He had lost both hands in a military accident when a defective explosive detonated during a training exercise. He later appeared in the Army rehabilitation film Diary of a Sergeant, and Wyler recognized that he could bring something extraordinary to the role of Homer Parrish. And he certainly did.

Homer's story breaks my heart because his greatest struggle isn't simply learning to live with his disability. It's the fear that everyone will look at him differently, that he'll become an object of pity, or worse, a burden to the people he loves.


 
Cathy O'Donnell as Wilma Cameron

He returns home to his family and to Wilma (Cathy O'Donnell), the young woman who loved him before the war. But Homer can't quite believe that she could possibly feel the same way about him now.


And Wilma, his sweetheart. What a lovely character. She doesn't pretend Homer's injuries don't exist, nor does she treat him as someone who needs pity. She just wants him to understand that she loves him, exactly as she always has. Their bedroom scene, in which Homer demonstrates how he removes his prosthetic hooks and prepares for bed, is almost unbearably moving. He's showing Wilma the reality of his everyday life, terrified that what she sees might change her feelings.


Russell's role was recognized in a historic way at the Academy Awards. He received a special honorary Oscar for bringing hope and courage to fellow veterans, and then won the competitive award for Best Supporting Actor. He remains the only performer to receive two Oscars for the same performance.


 

And how wonderful is Hoagy Carmichael as Homer's uncle Butch? His easygoing warmth and piano playing provide some of the film's loveliest moments of companionship. He's one of those supporting characters who makes the film's entire world feel more lived-in.




 

The Women Who Helped Them Find Their Way Home

And what about the women? Milly, Peggy, and Wilma. I don't think these three get nearly enough credit for what they bring to the story. That's something I find especially important about the women in this film. They weren't simply sitting at home waiting for their men to return. They had been living through the war themselves, managing households, raising children, working, worrying, and making decisions in their husbands' absence. Now they were expected to adjust all over again.

And then the men finally returned. Wonderful! The waiting was over, the families were reunited, and everything could go back to normal. Except it couldn't, could it? The men who came home weren't necessarily the same men who had left. They carried memories, nightmares, frustrations, and insecurities that their families couldn't fully understand. And now the women, who had already spent years keeping things going, found themselves helping their husbands and sweethearts adjust to a world that no longer seemed familiar. Something else I find fascinating is that each of these women has a particularly intimate scene with the man she loves. Three very different moments, but all showing us just how important these women are to the story.

There's Milly and that beautiful homecoming scene with Al, when she sees him standing at the other end of the hallway and runs into his arms. But the reunion is only the beginning. In the scenes that follow, we watch her trying to understand and navigate her husband's emotions, his restlessness, and his drinking. She knows something has changed in him, and she's trying to figure out how they can find their way back to each other.

 

Then there's Peggy, comforting Fred during that terrible nightmare. He's reliving the horrors of combat, and she sees a side of him that most people never do. I love the tenderness of that scene. She doesn't panic or demand explanations. She's simply there, helping him through something he can't control.


And finally, Wilma and that heartbreaking bedroom scene with Homer. He shows her how he removes his hooks and prepares for bed, letting her see what life with him would actually be like. He's so afraid that she'll pity him or change her mind about marrying him. But Wilma doesn't flinch. She helps him and, in doing so, makes it clear that she understands what their future together will involve. She loves Homer, not the hands he lost.


 

Three women, three very different relationships, and three scenes that say so much without much dialogue. And I think that's one of the things Wyler understood so well. These women weren't simply waiting at home for the happy ending. They were part of what came afterward, when everyone had to figure out how to live again.

What I appreciate is that Wyler doesn't portray these women as helpless figures waiting to be rescued. Quite the opposite. They have strength, opinions, and lives of their own. Their love and understanding don't magically erase what the men have experienced, but they certainly help them begin to heal. And that, to me, is just as much a part of the story as the men's homecoming. I appreciated it when I first studied the film for my college thesis, and I find it even more meaningful today. I also find it interesting how much this film meant to the actors themselves. 

 

Dana Andrews considered Fred Derry one of the defining roles of his career and appreciated that the film didn't offer easy answers to the problems returning veterans faced.

Fredric March, a World War I veteran himself, could relate to Al's difficulties adjusting to civilian life, particularly his return to the banking world. He considered the film among his finest screen achievements, although he didn't attend the Academy Awards ceremony when he won Best Actor.

Myrna Loy, while continuing to make films during World War II, spent much of those years volunteering with the American Red Cross and supporting the war effort. So playing Milly, a woman welcoming her husband home after years of war, felt especially fitting. Loy herself considered The Best Years of Our Lives among her finest work.

Teresa Wright welcomed the chance to play Peggy as an ordinary young woman rather than a glamorous Hollywood sweetheart. As a nurse, Peggy had already seen the realities of war and understood what men were going through. Wright wanted her to look authentic, wearing everyday clothes and minimal makeup. She admired Wyler's insistence on realism and considered The Best Years of Our Lives a personal favorite, even though she'd already won an Oscar for another wartime film, Mrs. Miniver (1942), also directed by Wyler.

Virginia Mayo had quite a different challenge playing Marie, Fred's selfish and unfaithful wife. It was a departure from her usual glamorous roles, and she was nervous about working with the demanding Wyler. She even hired a private acting coach to prepare. Mayo later recalled that when Wyler accepted her opening scenes without asking for retakes, she knew she was doing something right!

And then there's Harold Russell, who had never acted professionally and was initially hesitant about taking the role. Having lost both hands during military training, he understood Homer's struggles firsthand. The film became an important part of Russell's life and gave him a platform to advocate for disabled veterans.


Gregg Toland and the Beauty of Visual Storytelling

Of course, I can't discuss The Best Years of Our Lives without mentioning Gregg Toland's magnificent cinematography.


Toland, whose work on Citizen Kane (1941) helped revolutionize the way films were photographed, brought his extraordinary deep-focus photography to Wyler's film. His compositions let us see so much happening within a single frame, often telling us as much about the characters as the dialogue does.

One of my favorite examples is in Butch's bar, where Fred appears in a distant telephone booth while Al, Homer, and Butch occupy different areas of the scene. Rather than cutting back and forth between close-ups, Wyler and Toland let us take it all in.

 


And that's what I find so brilliant about Toland's photography. There's so much to look at, yet your eye somehow knows exactly where to go. Nothing feels forced or overly clever. It all serves the story and the people in it.

Gregg Toland's cinematography uses the window framing and depth to emphasize the emotional distance between them.

 

I also have a special fondness for Toland's work because I actually met his daughter,  Lothian, who was married to Red Skelton and is his widow, during my Red Skelton road trip, an experience I previously wrote about on my blog. 
 

 

I also have to mention Hugo Friedhofer's beautiful musical score, which adds so much emotion without overwhelming the drama. Then there's Daniel Mandell's editing, helping bring everything together so naturally that, even at nearly three hours, the film never feels too long. I wouldn't remove a single scene.

 

Eighty Years Later, Why Does It Still Matter?

When The Best Years of Our Lives was released, it spoke directly to a nation confronting the realities of peace after years of war. It dealt with unemployment, disability, troubled marriages, emotional trauma, class differences, and the difficulties of returning to a society that had continued changing while its servicemen were away. And it didn't offer easy answers.

The film became an enormous critical and commercial success, winning seven competitive Academy Awards, including Best Picture, Best Director, and Best Actor. But awards alone don't explain its greatness.


 

The film's humanity matters most.  Wyler understood that coming home wasn't simply about walking through the front door. It meant finding your place in the world again, reconnecting with people you loved, accepting changes you couldn't control, and somehow figuring out how to begin again. And I think that's why the film still resonates. 

It also represents everything I love about the art of cinema. The storytelling, direction, cinematography, performances, music, and emotional depth all come together so beautifully. Nothing feels unnecessary or out of place. Every character matters, and every scene hits you right in the heart. That's what makes it a perfect film in my eyes.


I've spent nearly thirty years loving this movie, and one of my greatest pleasures is introducing it to people who have never seen it. I always hope they'll discover even a little of what I felt when I first saw it. I've seen countless wonderful films over the years, admired so many directors, and fallen in love with more performances than I could possibly count. But nothing has ever quite displaced The Best Years of Our Lives.

Eighty years after its release, it still makes me smile, think, ache, and occasionally reach for a tissue. This film made me appreciate classic cinema on an entirely different level, and it's a big part of why sharing and celebrating these wonderful old movies means so much to me.

And every time Al walks through that door, and Milly runs into his arms, I go right back to being emotional over a scene I've watched more times than I can count. That's the wonderful thing about this movie. I know the story, I know the dialogue, and I know exactly what's coming. But it still gets me.